Truthful speech and entrenched slander
Stephanus reference page 17 — Stephanus reference page 19 · Close reading
Socrates asks the jurors to assess whether his words are just rather than polished. Before confronting the present prosecutors, he addresses an older image of himself as a speculative natural philosopher and manipulative teacher. Comedy and paid education supply elements of this image. Because these accusers cannot be summoned for questioning, the opening identifies a procedural difficulty: a brief trial must answer prejudices formed over many years.
Passages to examine
- 17a–d: the request about speaking style ↗
Consider how the reply to the charge of clever speaking itself establishes a relationship with the audience.
- 18b–e: the two classes of accusers ↗
Distinguish responding to an entrenched reputation from responding to identifiable prosecutors.
Question
Why does Socrates answer old slanders before the current indictment?
Viewpoints for an answer
- Old slanders were absorbed in childhood, and their authors cannot be called for cross-examination. That reputation also shapes how the present indictment is received.
- The opening request concerning his speaking style asks for just judgment, while also presenting the speaker as trustworthy; its rhetorical function deserves attention.
Key concepts:Prejudice and slanderJustice and avoiding wrongdoing