Rational Decision-Making in Business Organizations

Herbert A. Simon · Original publication / lecture: 1978

This theory explains choosing satisfactory options within cost and time limits.

Study the whole work ↓

Study the whole work

Follow the work’s structure and connect its central question, key concepts and assignments. Each unit’s reading questions are original tasks to consider with the work open. The edition and scope section identifies the materials checked and their limits.

The question of the whole work

How does a theory of human choice change our understanding of organizations and economic policy?

Edition and complete scope

Edition
Nobel Memorial Lecture, 8 December 1978; NobelPrize.org PDF
Scope
Reading divisions of the text: 6 · Opening: economics and human choice — Conclusion: comparing theories and policy judgments
Edition and editorial divisions
The reference list is excluded. Parts are editorial reading groups. Original division order is preserved. Descriptive labels, parts and learning units are editorial reading aids.
Checked
2026-11-17

Verification scope

Structure checked against: Public text

The official PDF text extraction provides the section structure and relevant arguments from the opening through the conclusion. Direct PDF download returned 403. References are outside the reading divisions; labels are editorial descriptions.

  1. Opening: economics and human choice ↗
  2. The scope of decision theory ↗
  3. Organizational mechanisms of bounded rationality ↗
  4. Examining the neoclassical response ↗
  5. Behavioral evidence and theories of firms ↗
  6. Conclusion: comparing theories and policy judgments ↗

Choose a reading path

Follow the structure of the work

Open each part for its scope, account, key passages and questions. Close reading revisits passages; reading follows their development; a survey identifies their role in the whole.

Economic questions and ways of testing them

Opening: economics and human choice — The scope of decision theory

Consider what economics should explain, separating agreement about outcomes from evidence about decision processes.

How far should economics study choice?

Opening: economics and human choice — Opening: economics and human choice · Read

Start with the opening view of economics and identify questions missed when inquiry examines only allocation outcomes.

Passages to examine in the work

Question

What needs investigation inside an organization before treating it as a single decision maker?

Viewpoints for an answer

  • Separate individual choice, organizational coordination and market outcomes as objects of analysis.
  • Propose one phenomenon together with evidence that could reveal it.

Key concepts:Bounded rationality

Distinguishing theories with similar outcomes

The scope of decision theory — The scope of decision theory · Close reading

Examine whether agreement with aggregate outcomes selects a theory, and compare evidence needed for description and prescription.

Passages to examine in the work

  • The scope of decision theory ↗

    Reading question: Open the first main section and inspect why examples involving demand or cost admit multiple explanations, then examine the computational conditions of prescriptive decisions.

Question

What observation could distinguish two theories that explain the same change in demand?

Viewpoints for an answer

  • Separate conditions producing identical predictions from those producing different predictions.
  • Suggest observing search procedures and information use as well as outcomes.

Key concepts:Discriminating evidenceProcedural rationality

Comparing mechanisms of decision

Organizational mechanisms of bounded rationality — Examining the neoclassical response

Map the constraints addressed by search and organizational specialization, then compare the assumptions of competing theories.

Builds on:Economic questions and ways of testing them

Connecting limits with organizational mechanisms

Organizational mechanisms of bounded rationality — Organizational mechanisms of bounded rationality · Close reading

Represent bounded rationality through problem formulation, search, subgoals and specialization rather than treating it only as individual weakness.

Passages to examine in the work

Question

What becomes tractable, and what may drift, when a broad goal is divided into departmental goals?

Viewpoints for an answer

  • Explain how the arrangement reduces information and computation demands.
  • Consider whether a measurable departmental target can displace the organization’s broader purpose.

Key concepts:Bounded rationalitySatisficingProblem representation

Are information costs enough?

Examining the neoclassical response — Examining the neoclassical response · Read

Read the criticism of neoclassical developments and distinguish adding information scarcity from explaining computation and search.

Passages to examine in the work

Question

What computational questions remain when a model also optimizes the cost of obtaining information?

Viewpoints for an answer

  • List the knowledge and computational capacities granted to the decision maker.
  • Identify both the criticized assumptions and what the competing model helps clarify.

Key concepts:Procedural rationalityBounded rationality

From accumulated evidence to policy judgment

Behavioral evidence and theories of firms — Conclusion: comparing theories and policy judgments

Distinguish experimental and field evidence, then examine how assumptions about individual choice can affect policy predictions.

Builds on:Comparing mechanisms of decision

What can experiments and cases establish?

Behavioral evidence and theories of firms — Behavioral evidence and theories of firms · Read

Organize advances by method, comparing choice experiments, problem solving, organizational cases and behavioral firm models.

Passages to examine in the work

Question

How does a case being consistent with a theory differ from a demanding test of that theory?

Viewpoints for an answer

  • Match each method of collecting evidence with the claims it can support.
  • Explain the roles and limitations of accumulated cases and simulation.

Key concepts:Organizational decision processDiscriminating evidence

Do policy conclusions depend on the assumptions?

Conclusion: comparing theories and policy judgments — Conclusion: comparing theories and policy judgments · Close reading

Read the conclusion against the earlier comparison and ask whether policy answers survive a change in decision-process assumptions.

Passages to examine in the work

Question

Which assumptions would you vary before relying on a policy prediction?

Viewpoints for an answer

  • Explain how changed and unchanged predictions would affect your confidence.
  • Identify further observations needed without treating bounded-rationality theory as a universal predictor.

Key concepts:Sensitivity analysisOrganizational decision process

Return key concepts to the text

Bounded rationality
An approach to choice that takes limits on information, computation and search seriously. First unit to examine →
Procedural rationality
A perspective examining how a choice is reached under available conditions, not only the resulting choice. First unit to examine →
Discriminating evidence
The problem of finding observable prediction differences when several theories explain the same outcome. First unit to examine →
Satisficing
Searching for an alternative meeting a criterion rather than optimizing over every conceivable alternative. First unit to examine →
Problem representation
The formulation of goals, alternatives and constraints that shapes the search for a solution. First unit to examine →
Organizational decision process
The processes of communication, goal division, authority and learning that shape organizational choices. First unit to examine →
Sensitivity analysis
Checking how predictions or recommended actions change when important assumptions are varied. First unit to examine →

Avoiding misreadings

These are editorial examples of misreadings, with passages that help reconsider them.

An assignment connecting the whole work

Choose an organizational decision and build an outcome-focused model and a model including search, subgoals and communication. Specify discriminating observations and conditions under which the resulting operational or policy judgment changes.

  • Are the choice being described and the recommended decision procedure distinguished?
  • Does the answer connect theoretical comparison, organizational mechanisms and sensitivity of conclusions?
  • Does the answer identify needed evidence without treating a hypothetical example as an established result?

Parts to connect:Economic questions and ways of testing themComparing mechanisms of decisionFrom accumulated evidence to policy judgment