What Is History?

E. H. Carr · Original publication / lecture: 1961

Examines the dynamic dialogue between historian, context, and selected factual evidence.

Study the whole work ↓

Study the whole work

Follow the work’s structure and connect its central question, key concepts and assignments. Each unit’s reading questions are original tasks to consider with the work open. The edition and scope section identifies the materials checked and their limits.

The question of the whole work

How can historical accounts be examined by connecting evidence, interpretation, society, and expectations about the future?

Edition and complete scope

Edition
The original six lectures of What Is History?, 1961; structure also checked against Iwanami Shoten’s translated contents, ISBN 9784004130017.
Scope
Lectures: 6 · 1 · Historian and evidence — 6 · Broader horizons
Edition and editorial divisions
All six original lectures are followed in order using editorial part and unit headings, without mixing pagination across editions. Prefaces and notes are supporting material. Later editorial introductions and R. W. Davies’s posthumous notes are distinct from the 1961 lectures and outside this path.
Checked
2026-11-17

Verification scope

Structure checked against: Contents or section structure

Cross-checked Penguin metadata and description with Iwanami Shoten’s publisher-supplied contents in the Japan Books database, confirming all six lectures and their sequence. Full text and edition-specific pagination were not reviewed. Independent reading tasks do not treat Carr’s argument as the only position in historiography.

  1. 1 · Historian and evidence ↗
  2. 2 · Society and individuals ↗
  3. 3 · Science and judgment ↗
  4. 4 · Causes ↗
  5. 5 · Historical progress ↗
  6. 6 · Broader horizons ↗

Choose a reading path

Follow the structure of the work

Open each part for its scope, account, key passages and questions. Close reading revisits passages; reading follows their development; a survey identifies their role in the whole.

Read evidence together with the historian

1 · Historian and evidence — 2 · Society and individuals

Use the first two lectures to examine the historian selecting evidence and the society they inhabit. Investigate sources alongside the framing of questions.

Ask what makes a fact historically selected

1 · Historian and evidence — 1 · Historian and evidence · Close reading

Read lecture 1 by distinguishing traces of events, surviving records, and what an account emphasizes. Separate the presence of selection from permission to claim anything.

Passages to examine in the work

Question

Open lecture 1 and compare two brief records of the same event, distinguishing verifiable details from selected questions.

Viewpoints for an answer

  • Check who produced each record, when, and for what purpose.
  • Present agreement in evidence separately from differences in interpretation.

Key concepts:Historical fact

Investigate individuals and society

2 · Society and individuals — 2 · Society and individuals · Read

Read lecture 2 by considering both historical actors and historians within society. Formulate questions about outcomes not easily explained by individual intentions alone.

Passages to examine in the work

  • 2 · Society and individuals ↗

    Reading question: Look for an argument adding social conditions to individual explanation, and note what it clarifies and what remains.

Question

Using lecture 2, examine how adding social position, institutions, and historical conditions changes questions about someone’s action.

Viewpoints for an answer

  • Separate what was intended from what resulted.
  • Include the historian’s own time and position in the investigation.

Key concepts:Social locationHistorical fact

Examine explanation and judgment

3 · Science and judgment — 4 · Causes

Read the lectures on science, morality, and causation. Distinguish reasons that explain an event from reasons used to assess conduct.

Builds on:Read evidence together with the historian

Examine generalization and moral judgment

3 · Science and judgment — 3 · Science and judgment · Read

Read lecture 3 to investigate historical explanation and generalization. Where moral assessment matters, clarify how it differs from explaining what occurred.

Passages to examine in the work

Question

Choose a comparison with science or morality in lecture 3 and identify its value for history and the differences that remain.

Viewpoints for an answer

  • Distinguish claiming exact repetition from identifying relationships useful for comparison.
  • Do not identify explaining an action with justifying it.

Key concepts:GeneralizationSocial location

Organize multiple causes into an explanation

4 · Causes — 4 · Causes · Close reading

Read lecture 4 by distinguishing listing causes from explaining their relationships and significance. Ask what remains investigable after an appeal to contingency.

Passages to examine in the work

  • 4 · Causes ↗

    Reading question: At the discussion of contingency and explanation, check what you have chosen to explain.

Question

Open lecture 4, identify multiple causes of an event, and explain which question your ranking of them aims to answer.

Viewpoints for an answer

  • Distinguish triggers, background conditions, and mechanisms extending an outcome.
  • Separate actual events from counterfactual scenarios.

Key concepts:Causal explanationGeneralization

Reconsider progress and horizons

5 · Historical progress — 6 · Broader horizons

Read the final lectures to examine historical direction and the range of historical inquiry. Compare expectations from the author’s time with your own judgments.

Builds on:Examine explanation and judgment

Question standards of progress

5 · Historical progress — 5 · Historical progress · Read

Read lecture 5 to investigate standards for calling change progress. Keep the passage of time, acquisition of something, and a desirable direction conceptually distinct.

Passages to examine in the work

  • 5 · Historical progress ↗

    Reading question: Look for conditions in the author’s account of progress and retain differences from your own standards.

Question

Using lecture 5, choose a change described as progress and state what is judged better and for whom.

Viewpoints for an answer

  • State the evaluative standard and distinguish it from a description of change.
  • Examine gains and losses within the same scope.

Key concepts:Historical progress

Examine the scope of historical inquiry

6 · Broader horizons — 6 · Broader horizons · Read

Read the final lecture to consider changes in whose histories are studied and who narrates them. Compare the author’s historical outlook with areas you may overlook today.

Passages to examine in the work

  • 6 · Broader horizons ↗

    Reading question: Read lecture 6 on broadening the subjects and horizons of history, then compare it with lecture 1 to examine how selected facts and questions change.

Question

Open lecture 6, identify a region or group to add to a historical account you know, and propose additional sources and questions.

Viewpoints for an answer

  • Distinguish expanding the subject matter from forcing new subjects into an unchanged framework.
  • Do not identify the author’s expectations with later facts through hindsight.

Key concepts:Historical horizonSocial location

Return key concepts to the text

Historical fact
A fact selected and examined in historical writing, distinguishing the existence of traces from significance within an account. First unit to examine →
Social location
The temporal, social, and institutional conditions of actors and historians, investigated to understand claims and actions. First unit to examine →
Generalization
Considering relationships across particular events without necessarily claiming that events repeat identically. First unit to examine →
Causal explanation
Relating multiple causes and conditions to the question being explained, distinct from a list of factors. First unit to examine →
Historical progress
An account attributing direction or value to change, examined by asking what counts as improvement and for whom. First unit to examine →
Historical horizon
The range of regions, people, periods, and questions addressed by history, whose expansion also calls for reconsidering sources and frameworks. First unit to examine →

Avoiding misreadings

These are editorial examples of misreadings, with passages that help reconsider them.

  • Because facts are selected, a story inconsistent with evidence is equally valid.

    Read the relation of evidence and interpretation in lecture 1, distinguishing selection from the absence of evidential constraints.

    1 · Historian and evidence ↗
  • Knowing an important cause shows that the result was inevitable from the start.

    Use lecture 4 to distinguish explanatory reasons, conditions at the time, and unrealized possibilities.

    4 · Causes ↗
  • An argument about progress means every later period must be better.

    Check the standards and conditions of progress in lecture 5 rather than deriving value from chronology alone.

    5 · Historical progress ↗

An assignment connecting the whole work

Choose a short historical account and reread it for source selection, individuals and society, explanation and judgment, causes, standards of progress, and scope. Distinguish questions answerable through additional sources from questions of value or interpretation, then propose a revision.

  • Record social conditions of both the account’s maker and its subjects.
  • Reorganize a list of causes into an explanation answering a question.
  • Make the revision’s new selections and remaining exclusions explicit.

Parts to connect:Read evidence together with the historianExamine explanation and judgmentReconsider progress and horizons