Introduction: change and the explanation of adaptation
Introduction — Introduction · Read
Darwin introduces the South American observations that prompted his inquiry, the long preparation, and Wallace’s related conclusions. He presents the book as an abstract of a larger investigation with evidence necessarily abbreviated. Descent alone does not yet explain intricate adaptation. The planned route from domesticated variation to natural selection addresses that problem. The introduction affirms that species change while describing natural selection as the principal, not exclusive, means of modification.
Passages to examine
- Introduction, printed pp. 3–4: woodpecker and mistletoe ↗
Examine why direct environmental effects alone are said to leave adaptation and interdependence unexplained.
- End of introduction, printed p. 6: conclusion and qualification ↗
Distinguish the rejection of immutable species from the claim that selection is not the sole means of modification.
Question
Why is accepting common ancestry insufficient to solve Darwin’s problem?
Viewpoints for an answer
- The woodpecker and mistletoe illustrate detailed relations to environments and other organisms. An account of ancestry also needs a process explaining how those adaptations arise.
- Calling the book an abstract does not promise that all supporting evidence appears here. Distinguish confidence in the conclusion from constraints on the presentation of evidence.
Key concepts:Descent with modificationNatural selection