The Search for the Highest Good and the Human Function
Book 1 — Book 1 · Close reading
Book 1 opens by noting that every craft, inquiry, and action aims at some good. Aristotle argues for a supreme good desired entirely for itself, which commonly goes by the name of happiness (eudaimonia). Examining prevalent opinions, he explains why simple bodily pleasure reduces human life to animal appetite, why public honour is too dependent on those who bestow it, and why wealth is merely a means to other ends. Introducing the human function argument, he suggests that just as an artisan has a defining work, human goodness consists in the active life of the soul in accordance with rational excellence over a complete lifetime. In addressing bad luck, he acknowledges that catastrophic misfortunes can weigh down and damage a happy life, but maintains that a person of good character will endure hardships with dignity and never stoop to base actions.
Passages to examine
- Book I, Chapter 2 ↗
The highest good is chosen for its own sake and directs the broader goals of human communities under political inquiry.
- Book I, Chapter 7 ↗
The human function: flourishing consists in the active exercise of the rational soul expressing excellence over a complete life.
- Book I, Chapter 10 ↗
External goods and adversity: while catastrophic misfortunes like Priam's can crush happiness, noble people handle changing fortunes with dignity and will not become wretched through vile deeds.
Question
Why does Aristotle consider external fortune and personal character together when defining a complete, flourishing human life?
Viewpoints for an answer
- In I.5, honour is judged incomplete as a chief good because people seek it to confirm their own goodness, showing that character itself matters more than external praise.
- In I.7, the distinctive human function excludes basic vegetative growth and sensory feeling, focusing on the reasoned activities of the soul over a lifetime.
- In I.10, Aristotle balances internal excellence with external circumstance: severe misfortune hinders activities and impairs blessedness, yet a virtuous person preserves composure without ever acting basely.
Key concepts:Happiness (Eudaimonia)