# Good Strategy Bad Strategy

Richard Rumelt · 2011

Open the original and follow its chapters or sections with this study guide. Reading tasks are editorial assignments. Use the points to consider to examine your interpretation.

## Scope of source verification

Structure checked against: Contents or section structure

The publisher preview verifies the introduction, 18 chapters, three parts and introductory excerpt. The PRH page supplies a chapter 1 excerpt. Later chapter bodies were not verified in full.

- [Profile Books — official preview](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Authorized excerpt
- [Penguin Random House — publisher excerpt](https://penguinrandomhousehighereducation.com/book/?isbn=9780307886231) — Authorized excerpt

<a id="guide"></a>
## Read the whole work

Whole-work question: How can we examine a strategy that identifies a significant obstacle and connects policy with action?

Edition: Profile Books 2017 reissue, ISBN 9781781256176; originally published in 2011

Native units: Reading divisions of the text

Form: Argument

Scope and divisions: Endorsements, acknowledgments, index and the separate notes list are excluded. The introduction remains a reading division. Chapter descriptions are editorial. Original division order is preserved. Descriptive labels, parts and learning units are editorial reading aids.

Checked: 2026-11-17

### Reading paths

Short path: [From aspiration to a problem for inquiry](#guide-unit-obstacle-question) → [Connecting diagnosis, policy and action](#guide-unit-kernel-links) → [Examining linked systems through design](#guide-unit-links-design) → [Turning a strategy into testable questions](#guide-unit-hypothesis-learning) → [Examining personal and collective confidence](#guide-unit-independent-thought)

Full path: [From aspiration to a problem for inquiry](#guide-unit-obstacle-question) → [Observing connections among actions](#guide-unit-coherence-observation) → [Comparing effective insight with defective strategy](#guide-unit-quality-contrast) → [Connecting diagnosis, policy and action](#guide-unit-kernel-links) → [Considering concentration and reachable objectives](#guide-unit-leverage-objective) → [Examining linked systems through design](#guide-unit-links-design) → [Evaluating focus and growth separately](#guide-unit-focus-growth) → [Examining advantage beyond possession](#guide-unit-advantage-conditions) → [Comparing external change and internal inertia](#guide-unit-change-inertia) → [Reading one case through several concepts](#guide-unit-integrated-case) → [Turning a strategy into testable questions](#guide-unit-hypothesis-learning) → [Examining personal and collective confidence](#guide-unit-independent-thought)

### Parts and reading units

<a id="guide-part-kernel"></a>
#### Examining what counts as strategy

Native range: Introduction: obstacles and strategic questions — Chapter 5: Constructing a strategic kernel

Read the introduction and first part, recording aspirations, problem descriptions, policies and actions separately before examining their relationships.

<a id="guide-unit-obstacle-question"></a>
##### From aspiration to a problem for inquiry

Native range: Introduction: obstacles and strategic questions · Read

Open the introduction and turn a desired state and an obstacle into separate statements that can guide your reading.

Question: What would you ask after hearing an ambitious goal in order to examine an actionable policy?

Points to consider:

- Distinguish the desired state from the current obstacle.
- Identify evidence supporting the obstacle description and the parts that remain conjectural.

Concepts: [Diagnosis](#guide-concept-diagnosis)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Introduction: obstacles and strategic questions](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open the introduction and investigate where identifying an obstacle influences the choice of action.

<a id="guide-unit-coherence-observation"></a>
##### Observing connections among actions

Native range: Chapter 1: Why a strategy can surprise · Read

Read chapter 1 and map whether several actions address the same problem instead of isolating a striking move.

Question: What might be missed by explaining a case through only one action?

Points to consider:

- Record the sequence of actions and how they support one another.
- Separate later outcomes from information available at the time.

Concepts: [Coherence of action](#guide-concept-coherence), [Diagnosis](#guide-concept-diagnosis)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Chapter 1: Why a strategy can surprise](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 1 and arrange the chosen actions to investigate how they address a shared obstacle.

<a id="guide-unit-quality-contrast"></a>
##### Comparing effective insight with defective strategy

Native range: Chapter 2: Finding a source of effective action — Chapter 4: Why defective strategy is produced · Read

Read chapters 2–4 and examine persuasive language through choices made, supporting evidence and responses to obstacles.

Question: How would you distinguish an attractive description from an explanation that guides action?

Points to consider:

- Identify decisions actually made and decisions left unresolved.
- Describe differences among cases rather than explaining every success or failure with a single label.

Concepts: [Examining defective strategy](#guide-concept-bad-strategy), [Coherence of action](#guide-concept-coherence)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Chapter 2: Finding a source of effective action](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 2 and investigate what was observed when a source of effective action was identified.
- [Chapter 3: Recognizing defective strategy](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 3 and check which of obstacle, goal, policy or action is missing from a description.
- [Chapter 4: Why defective strategy is produced](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 4 and investigate reasons and organizational conditions for avoiding choices, rather than assuming an individual-skill explanation.

<a id="guide-unit-kernel-links"></a>
##### Connecting diagnosis, policy and action

Native range: Chapter 5: Constructing a strategic kernel · Close reading

Study chapter 5 and work on justifying the connections among diagnosis, policy and action rather than merely filling three boxes.

Question: Which questions would help compare two different policies proposed from the same diagnosis?

Points to consider:

- Explain which aspect of the obstacle each policy addresses.
- Check whether the actions implementing the policy are mutually consistent.

Concepts: [Guiding policy](#guide-concept-guiding-policy), [Diagnosis](#guide-concept-diagnosis), [Coherence of action](#guide-concept-coherence)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Chapter 5: Constructing a strategic kernel](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 5 and examine the links among diagnosis, guiding policy and coherent action in its examples.

<a id="guide-part-power"></a>
#### Comparing conditions for effective action

Native range: Chapter 6: Where to concentrate effort — Chapter 15: Connecting elements in a single case

Use the second part to examine concentration, links, design, growth and change within a chosen case, checking the conditions of each.

Depends on: [Examining what counts as strategy](#guide-part-kernel)

<a id="guide-unit-leverage-objective"></a>
##### Considering concentration and reachable objectives

Native range: Chapter 6: Where to concentrate effort — Chapter 7: Feasible objectives within reach · Read

Read chapters 6–7 and compare directing effort toward a consequential point with setting an objective the organization can act on.

Question: How would you check both the significance and feasibility of a small proposed move?

Points to consider:

- State the expected connection to outcomes as a hypothesis and identify evidence to test it.
- Separate capabilities already available from those that are missing.

Concepts: [Leverage](#guide-concept-leverage), [Guiding policy](#guide-concept-guiding-policy)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Chapter 6: Where to concentrate effort](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 6 and identify conditions considered when choosing where to direct effort.
- [Chapter 7: Feasible objectives within reach](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 7 and examine reachable objectives in relation to the actor’s capabilities and uncertainty.

<a id="guide-unit-links-design"></a>
##### Examining linked systems through design

Native range: Chapter 8: Constraints in linked systems — Chapter 9: Designing a coordinated response · Close reading

Read chapters 8–9 and distinguish improving individual measures from designing a response to interconnected constraints.

Question: What would you investigate when improving one element fails to improve the whole?

Points to consider:

- Map dependencies involving surrounding processes and other actions.
- Examine which constraints may need joint changes and the resources required.

Concepts: [Constraint in a linked system](#guide-concept-bottleneck), [Coherence of action](#guide-concept-coherence)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Chapter 8: Constraints in linked systems](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 8 and investigate the conditions connecting a component with the overall outcome.
- [Chapter 9: Designing a coordinated response](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 9 and examine the design of multiple actions in relation to available resources.

<a id="guide-unit-focus-growth"></a>
##### Evaluating focus and growth separately

Native range: Chapter 10: Recognizing a consistent focus — Chapter 11: Questioning the quality of growth · Read

In chapters 10–11, infer focus from connected actions and examine how proposals for greater scale affect that connection.

Question: How can a growth proposal be evaluated beyond the resulting size?

Points to consider:

- Clarify the problem or need around which effort is concentrated.
- Describe how growth changes required actions and constraints.

Concepts: [Focus](#guide-concept-focus), [Coherence of action](#guide-concept-coherence)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Chapter 10: Recognizing a consistent focus](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 10 and practice inferring a common focus from several policies.
- [Chapter 11: Questioning the quality of growth](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 11 and distinguish evaluating growth itself from evaluating its strategic role.

<a id="guide-unit-advantage-conditions"></a>
##### Examining advantage beyond possession

Native range: Chapter 12: Examining how advantage is used · Read

Read chapter 12 and turn a claim of possessing a strength into questions about relative advantage and its maintenance.

Question: Can possessing a strong resource alone establish future performance?

Points to consider:

- Specify the comparison and the activity or value being evaluated.
- Identify constraints on using the advantage and conditions that may change.

Concepts: [Relative advantage](#guide-concept-advantage)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Chapter 12: Examining how advantage is used](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 12 and formulate questions distinguishing having, developing and using an advantage.

<a id="guide-unit-change-inertia"></a>
##### Comparing external change and internal inertia

Native range: Chapter 13: Reading the direction of change — Chapter 14: Inertia and organizational disorder · Read

Use chapters 13–14 to chart environmental change and organizational responses separately, examining delay and loss of coordination.

Question: Which observations would make a claim of failing to respond to change concrete?

Points to consider:

- Separate external changes from actions the organization continued.
- Identify reasons routines persist and evidence needed to reconsider them.

Concepts: [Organizational inertia](#guide-concept-inertia), [Relative advantage](#guide-concept-advantage)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Chapter 13: Reading the direction of change](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 13 and investigate which observations the author uses to distinguish forms of change.
- [Chapter 14: Inertia and organizational disorder](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 14 and consider where inertia and disorder could be investigated in actions, institutions and coordination.

<a id="guide-unit-integrated-case"></a>
##### Reading one case through several concepts

Native range: Chapter 15: Connecting elements in a single case · Read

In chapter 15, first build a chronology without conceptual labels, then choose which earlier concepts the explanation requires.

Question: Does applying more concepts to a case necessarily improve the explanation?

Points to consider:

- Reconstruct the choices available before the outcome was known.
- For each concept, identify what it explains and what remains unexplained.

Concepts: [Coherence of action](#guide-concept-coherence), [Leverage](#guide-concept-leverage), [Relative advantage](#guide-concept-advantage)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Chapter 15: Connecting elements in a single case](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 15, record the chronology and action relationships, and inspect where concepts from the second part help the explanation.

<a id="guide-part-thinking"></a>
#### Examining the process of strategic thinking

Native range: Chapter 16: Treating a strategy as a hypothesis — Chapter 18: Maintaining distance from conformity

Use the third part to connect testing strategic hypotheses with examining personal and collective confidence.

Depends on: [Comparing conditions for effective action](#guide-part-power)

<a id="guide-unit-hypothesis-learning"></a>
##### Turning a strategy into testable questions

Native range: Chapter 16: Treating a strategy as a hypothesis · Close reading

Read chapter 16 and specify what a strategy predicts and what would prompt revision before selecting it by confidence alone.

Question: What observation would indicate that a strategy needs revision?

Points to consider:

- Distinguish the predicted change from the reason it is expected.
- Specify observation periods and evidence instead of explaining every result retrospectively.

Concepts: [Strategic hypothesis](#guide-concept-hypothesis), [Diagnosis](#guide-concept-diagnosis)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Chapter 16: Treating a strategy as a hypothesis](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 16 and use its connections among hypothesis, experience and learning to consider how a strategy could be examined.

<a id="guide-unit-independent-thought"></a>
##### Examining personal and collective confidence

Native range: Chapter 17: Examining a process of thought — Chapter 18: Maintaining distance from conformity · Read

Use chapters 17–18 to examine thinking procedures and conformity, practicing proposal generation separately from critical challenge.

Question: Which alternative questions should remain open when a plausible proposal gains widespread agreement?

Points to consider:

- Develop alternative explanations or options and compare them using the same criteria.
- Distinguish independent judgment from opposition for its own sake by comparing evidence.

Concepts: [Independent judgment](#guide-concept-independent-judgment), [Strategic hypothesis](#guide-concept-hypothesis)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Chapter 17: Examining a process of thought](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 17, choose a thinking procedure and use it to examine your proposal.
- [Chapter 18: Maintaining distance from conformity](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf) — Open chapter 18 and identify evidence worth checking when distancing yourself from collective confidence.

### Key concepts

<a id="guide-concept-diagnosis"></a>
#### Diagnosis

A focused explanation of a significant obstacle or situation that informs the consideration of action.

First unit: [From aspiration to a problem for inquiry](#guide-unit-obstacle-question)

<a id="guide-concept-coherence"></a>
#### Coherence of action

A relationship in which actions address a shared problem and policy without undermining one another.

First unit: [Observing connections among actions](#guide-unit-coherence-observation)

<a id="guide-concept-bad-strategy"></a>
#### Examining defective strategy

A way of checking whether goals and impressive language are accompanied by a significant obstacle and a response.

First unit: [Comparing effective insight with defective strategy](#guide-unit-quality-contrast)

<a id="guide-concept-guiding-policy"></a>
#### Guiding policy

An overall approach to a diagnosed challenge that directs the selection of particular actions.

First unit: [Connecting diagnosis, policy and action](#guide-unit-kernel-links)

<a id="guide-concept-leverage"></a>
#### Leverage

A conditional inquiry into where available effort may produce a consequential change.

First unit: [Considering concentration and reachable objectives](#guide-unit-leverage-objective)

<a id="guide-concept-bottleneck"></a>
#### Constraint in a linked system

A situation in which a component’s relationships with other components constrain overall results.

First unit: [Examining linked systems through design](#guide-unit-links-design)

<a id="guide-concept-focus"></a>
#### Focus

Concentrating several policies and actions around a selected problem or need.

First unit: [Evaluating focus and growth separately](#guide-unit-focus-growth)

<a id="guide-concept-advantage"></a>
#### Relative advantage

A capability or condition that helps create value relative to a specified comparison and setting.

First unit: [Examining advantage beyond possession](#guide-unit-advantage-conditions)

<a id="guide-concept-inertia"></a>
#### Organizational inertia

Difficulty changing routines or actions despite changed conditions; its causes and effects require investigation.

First unit: [Comparing external change and internal inertia](#guide-unit-change-inertia)

<a id="guide-concept-hypothesis"></a>
#### Strategic hypothesis

A revisable expectation about how a proposed action will work in a particular situation.

First unit: [Turning a strategy into testable questions](#guide-unit-hypothesis-learning)

<a id="guide-concept-independent-judgment"></a>
#### Independent judgment

Comparing alternative explanations and evidence rather than relying only on collective confidence or an initial proposal.

First unit: [Examining personal and collective confidence](#guide-unit-independent-thought)

### Misreadings and corrections (editorial examples)

Possible misreading: Filling three boxes completes a strategy.

Correction: Justify the links among diagnosis, policy and action and examine gaps or contradictions against the examples.

Check the passage: [Chapter 5: Constructing a strategic kernel](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)

Possible misreading: Using every method listed in the contents works for any problem.

Correction: Open the relevant chapters, investigate their conditions and select what the problem actually requires.

Check the passage: [Chapter 6: Where to concentrate effort](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)

Possible misreading: Independent thinking requires opposing every collective proposal.

Correction: Compare explanations, evidence and conditions for revising confidence before deciding agreement or disagreement.

Check the passage: [Chapter 18: Maintaining distance from conformity](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)

<a id="guide-capstone"></a>
### Capstone

Choose a challenge and connect diagnosis, guiding policy and coherent action on one page. Explain why selected concepts from the second part are relevant, then add an alternative proposal and observations that would prompt revision.

- Are goals distinguished from problems and policy from actions while their relationships are explained?
- Are relevance and conditions explained rather than maximizing the number of concepts used?
- Are the kernel, sources of effective action and critical testing connected?

Parts to connect: [Examining what counts as strategy](#guide-part-kernel), [Comparing conditions for effective action](#guide-part-power), [Examining the process of strategic thinking](#guide-part-thinking)

<a id="guide-scope"></a>
### Native scope inventory

1. [Introduction: obstacles and strategic questions](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
2. [Chapter 1: Why a strategy can surprise](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
3. [Chapter 2: Finding a source of effective action](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
4. [Chapter 3: Recognizing defective strategy](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
5. [Chapter 4: Why defective strategy is produced](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
6. [Chapter 5: Constructing a strategic kernel](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
7. [Chapter 6: Where to concentrate effort](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
8. [Chapter 7: Feasible objectives within reach](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
9. [Chapter 8: Constraints in linked systems](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
10. [Chapter 9: Designing a coordinated response](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
11. [Chapter 10: Recognizing a consistent focus](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
12. [Chapter 11: Questioning the quality of growth](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
13. [Chapter 12: Examining how advantage is used](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
14. [Chapter 13: Reading the direction of change](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
15. [Chapter 14: Inertia and organizational disorder](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
16. [Chapter 15: Connecting elements in a single case](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
17. [Chapter 16: Treating a strategy as a hypothesis](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
18. [Chapter 17: Examining a process of thought](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
19. [Chapter 18: Maintaining distance from conformity](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)

### Primary references

- [Profile Books — official preview](https://profilebooks.com/wp-content/uploads/wpallimport/files/PDFs/9781781256176_preview.pdf)
- [Penguin Random House — publisher excerpt](https://penguinrandomhousehighereducation.com/book/?isbn=9780307886231)


[Return to the learning courses](/en/lab/classics/learn)

[Download Markdown](/classics-data/modern/rumelt.en.md)
