# Beyond Markets and States

Elinor Ostrom · 2009

Open the original and follow its chapters or sections with this study guide. Reading tasks are editorial assignments. Use the points to consider to examine your interpretation.

## Scope of source verification

Structure checked against: Public text

The official PDF extraction verifies the opening and sections 1–8, including experiments, field comparisons, theory and reform. The scope does not replace it with the 2010 AER version. Direct PDF download returned 403.

- [Elinor Ostrom — Prize Lecture](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf) — Public text

<a id="guide"></a>
## Read the whole work

Whole-work question: Through which conditions and evidence can arrangements for shared resources and public services be compared?

Edition: Prize Lecture, 8 December 2009; NobelPrize.org PDF

Native units: Reading divisions of the text

Form: Argument

Scope and divisions: Acknowledgments and the bibliography are excluded. Short descriptions of sections are editorial. Original division order is preserved. Descriptive labels, parts and learning units are editorial reading aids.

Checked: 2026-11-17

### Reading paths

Short path: [Separating assumptions about institutions, goods and people](#guide-unit-simple-assumptions) → [Describing action situations with shared terms](#guide-unit-iad-description) → [Tracking conditions varied in experiments](#guide-unit-experiments-communication) → [What must be aligned in field comparisons?](#guide-unit-field-comparisons) → [Avoiding a single prescription for institutional reform](#guide-unit-reform-complexity)

Full path: [How did the research questions change?](#guide-unit-journey-question) → [Separating assumptions about institutions, goods and people](#guide-unit-simple-assumptions) → [Examining relationships among multiple centers](#guide-unit-polycentric-comparison) → [Describing action situations with shared terms](#guide-unit-iad-description) → [Reading institutional rules and conditions of persistence](#guide-unit-rules-institutions) → [Tracking conditions varied in experiments](#guide-unit-experiments-communication) → [What must be aligned in field comparisons?](#guide-unit-field-comparisons) → [Connecting theories of cooperation with conditions](#guide-unit-theory-trust) → [Avoiding a single prescription for institutional reform](#guide-unit-reform-complexity)

### Parts and reading units

<a id="guide-part-starting-points"></a>
#### From simple categories to investigation

Native range: Opening: the research journey and its questions — Section 2: Beginning the study of complex institutions

Read the research journey and early institutional assumptions, forming comparative questions rather than inferring outcomes from institutional labels.

<a id="guide-unit-journey-question"></a>
##### How did the research questions change?

Native range: Opening: the research journey and its questions · Read

Read the opening research journey and map the connections between questions and methods across water, services and resource governance.

Question: Before asking which institution performs better, which outcomes and conditions must be specified?

Points to consider:

- Specify the outcomes of interest without restricting them to efficiency.
- Identify differences between settings that a single institutional label cannot reveal.

Concepts: [Polycentricity](#guide-concept-polycentricity)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Opening: the research journey and its questions](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf) — Open the introduction, follow the expanding range of subjects and methods, and identify questions left open at the outset.

<a id="guide-unit-simple-assumptions"></a>
##### Separating assumptions about institutions, goods and people

Native range: Section 1: Questioning simple institutional assumptions · Close reading

Read section 1 by separating assumptions about organizational form, types of goods and individual behavior.

Question: When considering something shared, which properties matter besides the identity of its owner?

Points to consider:

- Distinguish the difficulty of exclusion from the effects of one person’s use on others.
- Avoid jumping directly from a good’s properties to one institutional prescription.

Concepts: [Properties of goods](#guide-concept-resource-properties)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Section 1: Questioning simple institutional assumptions](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf) — Open section 1 and list its simplifying assumptions separately for organizations, goods and individuals.

<a id="guide-unit-polycentric-comparison"></a>
##### Examining relationships among multiple centers

Native range: Section 2: Beginning the study of complex institutions · Read

Read the service studies in section 2, attending to provision, production and coordination rather than only counting organizations.

Question: How can multiple organizations be compared without assuming either waste or effectiveness?

Points to consider:

- Separate conditions of scale and cooperation for different service tasks.
- Develop questions about communication, competition and agreements among centers.

Concepts: [Polycentricity](#guide-concept-polycentricity), [Properties of goods](#guide-concept-resource-properties)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Section 2: Beginning the study of complex institutions](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf) — Open section 2 and inspect how arrangements and outcomes were compared in studies of water and policing.

<a id="guide-part-framework-evidence"></a>
#### Reading diverse evidence through a shared framework

Native range: Section 3: A framework for describing diverse situations — Section 6: Comparing institutions in the field

Map action situations and institutional rules, then distinguish the claims supported by cases, experiments and field comparisons.

Depends on: [From simple categories to investigation](#guide-part-starting-points)

<a id="guide-unit-iad-description"></a>
##### Describing action situations with shared terms

Native range: Section 3: A framework for describing diverse situations · Close reading

Use section 3 to describe participants, actions, information and outcomes in one situation, distinguishing framework, theory and model.

Question: Which common fields would you record when comparing two groups using a similar resource?

Points to consider:

- Specify who participates, what they know and which actions are available.
- Distinguish a descriptive framework from a particular theory predicting outcomes.

Concepts: [Institutional Analysis and Development framework](#guide-concept-iad), [Framework, theory and model](#guide-concept-framework-theory-model)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Section 3: A framework for describing diverse situations](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf) — Open section 3, read the components of an action situation from the diagram and use them as descriptive fields for a familiar shared setting.

<a id="guide-unit-rules-institutions"></a>
##### Reading institutional rules and conditions of persistence

Native range: Section 4: Investigating dilemmas around shared resources · Close reading

Read the resource cases in section 4, distinguishing what particular rules change from conditions associated with institutional persistence.

Question: When learning from a successful case, can its institutional rules simply be transplanted?

Points to consider:

- Distinguish where rules affect participation, information, costs or benefits.
- Identify local and resource conditions and distinguish principles from specific rules.

Concepts: [Institutional rules](#guide-concept-institutional-rules), [Institutional Analysis and Development framework](#guide-concept-iad)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Section 4: Investigating dilemmas around shared resources](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf) — Open section 4 and compare the classifications of rules and conditions of institutional persistence, checking whether they serve the same purpose.

<a id="guide-unit-experiments-communication"></a>
##### Tracking conditions varied in experiments

Native range: Section 5: Experimental conditions and cooperation · Read

Read the experiments in section 5, separating communication, sanctions and imposed rules as conditions and identifying each comparison.

Question: How far can an experiment showing greater cooperation inform expectations in a field setting?

Points to consider:

- Distinguish manipulated conditions, observed behavior and measured outcomes.
- Specify differences in participants and setting, leaving questions to test outside the experiment.

Concepts: [Experimental comparison](#guide-concept-experimental-comparison), [Trust in interaction](#guide-concept-trust)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Section 5: Experimental conditions and cooperation](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf) — Open section 5, tabulate communication and rule conditions for each experiment and identify the outcome comparison.

<a id="guide-unit-field-comparisons"></a>
##### What must be aligned in field comparisons?

Native range: Section 6: Comparing institutions in the field · Read

Compare irrigation and forest studies in section 6, examining environmental differences and outcome measures as well as governance labels.

Question: When governance and outcomes are associated in the field, which alternative explanations need checking?

Points to consider:

- Compare resource conditions, users and actual monitoring or operating practices.
- Distinguish observing an association from identifying a single cause.

Concepts: [Field comparison](#guide-concept-field-comparison), [Institutional rules](#guide-concept-institutional-rules)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Section 6: Comparing institutions in the field](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf) — Open section 6, compare outcome measures for irrigation and forests and examine how environmental differences are handled.

<a id="guide-part-theory-reform"></a>
#### Returning theory and reform to their conditions

Native range: Section 7: Connecting theory with contextual conditions — Section 8: Reform informed by complexity

Ask about conditions of cooperation and failure, connecting them with judgments about institutional change in complex settings.

Depends on: [Reading diverse evidence through a shared framework](#guide-part-framework-evidence)

<a id="guide-unit-theory-trust"></a>
##### Connecting theories of cooperation with conditions

Native range: Section 7: Connecting theory with contextual conditions · Read

Read trust, learning and norms in section 7 in relation to repeated interactions and information rather than only personal traits.

Question: How would you turn a statement that trust exists into observable comparative questions?

Points to consider:

- Specify opportunities to learn past behavior and arrangements for checking commitments.
- Compare conditions supporting cooperation with those making it difficult for the same people.

Concepts: [Trust in interaction](#guide-concept-trust), [Framework, theory and model](#guide-concept-framework-theory-model)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Section 7: Connecting theory with contextual conditions](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf) — Open section 7, distinguish accounts of individuals from accounts of their situations and identify connections between them.

<a id="guide-unit-reform-complexity"></a>
##### Avoiding a single prescription for institutional reform

Native range: Section 8: Reform informed by complexity · Close reading

Connect section 8 with the earlier evidence and consider how proposals include context, learning and revision after failure.

Question: What would you investigate, and with whom would you deliberate, before changing resource governance?

Points to consider:

- Identify affected participants and the scope of authority to change rules.
- Specify conditions for reviewing outcomes and side effects rather than relying on a uniform prescription.

Concepts: [Fit with context](#guide-concept-context-fit), [Polycentricity](#guide-concept-polycentricity), [Institutional Analysis and Development framework](#guide-concept-iad)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Section 8: Reform informed by complexity](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf) — Open section 8, trace reform proposals back to the experiments and field studies and examine how far the evidence supports them.

### Key concepts

<a id="guide-concept-polycentricity"></a>
#### Polycentricity

An arrangement with multiple decision centers that have some autonomy and operate in relation to one another.

First unit: [How did the research questions change?](#guide-unit-journey-question)

<a id="guide-concept-resource-properties"></a>
#### Properties of goods

Properties including difficulty of exclusion and how one person’s use affects what remains available to others.

First unit: [Separating assumptions about institutions, goods and people](#guide-unit-simple-assumptions)

<a id="guide-concept-iad"></a>
#### Institutional Analysis and Development framework

A framework for examining action situations and their surrounding conditions through shared analytical fields.

First unit: [Describing action situations with shared terms](#guide-unit-iad-description)

<a id="guide-concept-framework-theory-model"></a>
#### Framework, theory and model

A distinction among general descriptive organization, explanatory assumptions and a specific representation under stated conditions.

First unit: [Describing action situations with shared terms](#guide-unit-iad-description)

<a id="guide-concept-institutional-rules"></a>
#### Institutional rules

Arrangements governing participation, actions, information, outcomes and the distribution of costs and benefits.

First unit: [Reading institutional rules and conditions of persistence](#guide-unit-rules-institutions)

<a id="guide-concept-experimental-comparison"></a>
#### Experimental comparison

A method comparing behavior or outcomes while varying conditions such as communication or rules.

First unit: [Tracking conditions varied in experiments](#guide-unit-experiments-communication)

<a id="guide-concept-trust"></a>
#### Trust in interaction

Expectations about others’ behavior formed through experience, information and repeated relationships.

First unit: [Tracking conditions varied in experiments](#guide-unit-experiments-communication)

<a id="guide-concept-field-comparison"></a>
#### Field comparison

Comparing actual arrangements and outcomes while considering differences in environments and users.

First unit: [What must be aligned in field comparisons?](#guide-unit-field-comparisons)

<a id="guide-concept-context-fit"></a>
#### Fit with context

An inquiry into how particular rules relate to resource, user and surrounding institutional conditions.

First unit: [Avoiding a single prescription for institutional reform](#guide-unit-reform-complexity)

### Misreadings and corrections (editorial examples)

Possible misreading: A communal ownership label guarantees successful resource management.

Correction: Investigate rules, monitoring, cost sharing and local conditions, distinguishing ownership labels from actual operation.

Check the passage: [Section 4: Investigating dilemmas around shared resources](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf)

Possible misreading: The research proves that user management always outperforms government.

Correction: Read the comparison groups, outcomes and conditions rather than extending a result unconditionally to other settings.

Check the passage: [Section 6: Comparing institutions in the field](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf)

Possible misreading: More complicated problems always require more detailed rules.

Correction: Examine which interactions or information gaps a rule addresses and compare the burdens of operating and revising it.

Check the passage: [Section 8: Reform informed by complexity](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf)

<a id="guide-capstone"></a>
### Capstone

Choose a resource shared in a community or school. Describe its properties, action situation, participants, rules and outcomes. Compare two arrangements, distinguish experimental questions from field questions and propose conditions for revision.

- Are particular rules compared rather than inferring outcomes from institutional labels or ownership?
- Does the answer connect initial assumptions, the framework, experiments, field studies and conditions of reform?
- Are both possible cooperation and possible failure examined?

Parts to connect: [From simple categories to investigation](#guide-part-starting-points), [Reading diverse evidence through a shared framework](#guide-part-framework-evidence), [Returning theory and reform to their conditions](#guide-part-theory-reform)

<a id="guide-scope"></a>
### Native scope inventory

1. [Opening: the research journey and its questions](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf)
2. [Section 1: Questioning simple institutional assumptions](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf)
3. [Section 2: Beginning the study of complex institutions](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf)
4. [Section 3: A framework for describing diverse situations](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf)
5. [Section 4: Investigating dilemmas around shared resources](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf)
6. [Section 5: Experimental conditions and cooperation](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf)
7. [Section 6: Comparing institutions in the field](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf)
8. [Section 7: Connecting theory with contextual conditions](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf)
9. [Section 8: Reform informed by complexity](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf)

### Primary references

- [Elinor Ostrom — Prize Lecture](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/ostrom_lecture.pdf)


[Return to the learning courses](/en/lab/classics/learn)

[Download Markdown](/classics-data/modern/ostrom.en.md)
