# Exploration and Exploitation in Organizational Learning

James G. March · 1991

Open the original and follow its chapters or sections with this study guide. Reading tasks are editorial assignments. Use the points to consider to examine your interpretation.

## Scope of source verification

Structure checked against: Public text

Checked INFORMS metadata and abstract against the original paper publicly hosted by San José State University, including four sections, two models, figure conditions, conclusion, and reference locations. Simulations were not reproduced and practical effects were not tested. Questions and diagramming tasks are editorial.

- [INFORMS: original article metadata and abstract](https://pubsonline.informs.org/doi/10.1287/orsc.2.1.71) — Authorized excerpt
- [San José State University: original research article used in teaching](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf) — Public text

<a id="guide"></a>
## Read the whole work

Whole-work question: How can models help us examine conditions under which learning improves current performance while narrowing future possibilities?

Edition: Organization Science, volume 2, issue 1, 1991, pp.71–87. DOI:10.1287/orsc.2.1.71.

Native units: Opening, numbered sections, and references

Form: Argument

Scope and divisions: Six divisions cover the opening, sections 1–4, and references. Since section boundaries share pages, divisions follow verified sections rather than page ranges. Acknowledgments are supporting material at the end of section 4. Editorial parts and units do not convert conditional model results into universal organizational recommendations.

Checked: 2026-11-17

### Reading paths

Short path: [Compare distributed costs and benefits](#guide-unit-tradeoff) → [Read the mutual-learning model](#guide-unit-mutual-model) → [Distinguish performance from rank](#guide-unit-competitive-model) → [Ask what small models establish](#guide-unit-limits)

Full path: [Ask about two forms of learning](#guide-unit-opening) → [Compare distributed costs and benefits](#guide-unit-tradeoff) → [Read the mutual-learning model](#guide-unit-mutual-model) → [Distinguish performance from rank](#guide-unit-competitive-model) → [Ask what small models establish](#guide-unit-limits) → [Investigate the research connections](#guide-unit-references)

### Parts and reading units

<a id="guide-part-problem"></a>
#### Define the allocation problem

Native range: Opening problem — 1 · The trade-off

Read the opening and first section to distinguish exploration and exploitation by where and when costs and benefits occur.

<a id="guide-unit-opening"></a>
##### Ask about two forms of learning

Native range: Opening problem · Read

Read the opening problem without classifying exploration and exploitation solely by activity names. Specify the resource being allocated and the outcomes being compared.

Question: Read the opening, identify activities that may involve exploration or exploitation, and retain one ambiguous case.

Points to consider:

- Distinguish novelty of an activity from its role in developing existing competence.
- Specify whose time or other costs are being allocated.

Concepts: [Exploration](#guide-concept-exploration), [Exploitation](#guide-concept-exploitation)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [Opening problem](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf) — Return to the definitions and consider when the same activity could serve a different role.

<a id="guide-unit-tradeoff"></a>
##### Compare distributed costs and benefits

Native range: 1 · The trade-off · Close reading

Read section 1 by distinguishing timing, recipients within the organization, and external competition. Avoid immediately converting allocation into one fixed ratio.

Question: Choose two allocation difficulties from section 1 and construct an example evaluated differently in the short and long run.

Points to consider:

- Show whether the people bearing costs are also those receiving the benefits.
- Identify which assessment changes when the evaluation time changes.

Concepts: [Exploration](#guide-concept-exploration), [Exploitation](#guide-concept-exploitation), [Distributed costs and returns](#guide-concept-distributed-returns)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [1 · The trade-off](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf) — At the discussion of time and participants, inspect the assumptions in your own example.

<a id="guide-part-mutual-learning"></a>
#### Trace learning by people and organization

Native range: 2 · Mutual learning

Read the assumptions, update rules, and results in section 2. Keep individual knowledge distinct from knowledge represented in the organizational code.

Depends on: [Define the allocation problem](#guide-part-problem)

<a id="guide-unit-mutual-model"></a>
##### Read the mutual-learning model

Native range: 2 · Mutual learning · Close reading

In section 2, trace how the organizational code and individual beliefs change. Read learning rates, personnel turnover, and environmental change as distinct conditions.

Question: Diagram who learns from whom in section 2, then explain one assumption that could change the resulting pattern.

Points to consider:

- Track knowledge in the organizational code separately from knowledge of an average individual.
- Distinguish newcomers’ amount of knowledge from its difference from existing knowledge.

Concepts: [Organizational code](#guide-concept-organizational-code), [Socialization](#guide-concept-socialization), [Model assumption](#guide-concept-model-assumption)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [2 · Mutual learning](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf) — Move between the model definition and figures, recording what condition changed and what was measured.

<a id="guide-part-competition-and-limits"></a>
#### Examine competition and model limits

Native range: 3 · Competition — References

Read the competitive setting in section 3, then return to section 4 and the references. Distinguish average performance from relative rank and assumptions from practical decisions.

Depends on: [Trace learning by people and organization](#guide-part-mutual-learning)

<a id="guide-unit-competitive-model"></a>
##### Distinguish performance from rank

Native range: 3 · Competition · Close reading

Read the competitive model in section 3 by distinguishing higher mean performance from the chance of ranking near the top. Attend to distributions and the number of rivals.

Question: Read section 3 and identify what must be compared under a mean-performance objective and a top-ranking objective.

Points to consider:

- Present the mean, variability, and number of competitors as separate conditions.
- Retain the distinction between seeking a high rank and avoiding a low rank.

Concepts: [Competitive ecology](#guide-concept-competitive-ecology), [Model assumption](#guide-concept-model-assumption)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [3 · Competition](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf) — Read the competitive conditions attached to a figure and check which objective is affected by increased variability.

<a id="guide-unit-limits"></a>
##### Ask what small models establish

Native range: 4 · Model implications · Read

Read section 4 to compare what the two models share and where they differ. Separate questions suggested by a model from decisions requiring additional evidence.

Question: Open section 4 and draft one workplace proposal, adding the local information required and what the paper alone cannot decide.

Points to consider:

- Write the model result and your proposed action in separate sentences.
- Address both reasons to sustain exploration and the costs exploration entails.

Concepts: [Model assumption](#guide-concept-model-assumption), [Distributed costs and returns](#guide-concept-distributed-returns)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [4 · Model implications](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf) — Look for qualifications in the conclusion and check whether your proposal goes beyond them.

<a id="guide-unit-references"></a>
##### Investigate the research connections

Native range: References · Survey

Use the references to investigate the research areas connected to the paper. Distinguish an account of one paper from claims about agreement across a field.

Question: Choose a reference, locate its use in the paper, and formulate one question for further investigation.

Points to consider:

- Distinguish a work being cited from having checked its conclusions.
- Clarify whether the next reading is for checking assumptions, comparison, or seeking counterexamples.

Concepts: [Model assumption](#guide-concept-model-assumption)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [References](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf) — Move between the citation in the text and the reference entry to examine its role in the argument.

### Key concepts

<a id="guide-concept-exploration"></a>
#### Exploration

Activities that investigate possibilities not yet well understood; compare their timing and uncertainty with exploitation.

First unit: [Ask about two forms of learning](#guide-unit-opening)

<a id="guide-concept-exploitation"></a>
#### Exploitation

Activities that develop and use existing knowledge or competence; examine their function rather than labels alone.

First unit: [Ask about two forms of learning](#guide-unit-opening)

<a id="guide-concept-distributed-returns"></a>
#### Distributed costs and returns

The occurrence of learning costs and benefits at different times and for different people or organizations.

First unit: [Compare distributed costs and benefits](#guide-unit-tradeoff)

<a id="guide-concept-organizational-code"></a>
#### Organizational code

A representation of organizational beliefs in the mutual-learning model, not an automatic equivalent of a real manual or all collective knowledge.

First unit: [Read the mutual-learning model](#guide-unit-mutual-model)

<a id="guide-concept-socialization"></a>
#### Socialization

In the model, the process by which individuals learn from the organizational code; examine its speed and effects on organizational learning separately.

First unit: [Read the mutual-learning model](#guide-unit-mutual-model)

<a id="guide-concept-model-assumption"></a>
#### Model assumption

A condition imposed to make a complex phenomenon analyzable, whose relevance must be checked before applying results in practice.

First unit: [Read the mutual-learning model](#guide-unit-mutual-model)

<a id="guide-concept-competitive-ecology"></a>
#### Competitive ecology

A setting where the value of performance depends on rivals’ performance and number; distinguish absolute outcomes from relative position.

First unit: [Distinguish performance from rank](#guide-unit-competitive-model)

### Misreadings and corrections (editorial examples)

Possible misreading: Every organization should allocate equally to exploration and exploitation.

Correction: Specify the time horizon and whose costs and returns are counted before evaluating any proposed ratio.

Check the passage: [1 · The trade-off](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf)

Possible misreading: Because turnover can help, more turnover always improves organizational knowledge.

Correction: Check learning rates together with turnover conditions in section 2, and retain the conditional nature of the comparison.

Check the passage: [2 · Mutual learning](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf)

Possible misreading: Greater variability helps in every kind of competition.

Correction: Check ranking objectives and numbers of competitors in section 3, distinguishing mean performance and avoiding low ranks.

Check the passage: [3 · Competition](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf)

<a id="guide-capstone"></a>
### Capstone

Choose a proposal for making short training more efficient and reconsider it through both models. Identify expected outcomes, differences that could be lost, conditions to check locally, and decisions the paper alone cannot settle.

- Diagram who bears the costs and receives the benefits, and when.
- Separate assessments of individuals, the organizational code, and competitive rank.
- Connect each relevant model assumption with evidence to collect in practice.

Parts to connect: [Define the allocation problem](#guide-part-problem), [Trace learning by people and organization](#guide-part-mutual-learning), [Examine competition and model limits](#guide-part-competition-and-limits)

<a id="guide-scope"></a>
### Native scope inventory

1. [Opening problem](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf)
2. [1 · The trade-off](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf)
3. [2 · Mutual learning](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf)
4. [3 · Competition](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf)
5. [4 · Model implications](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf)
6. [References](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf)

### Primary references

- [INFORMS: original article metadata and abstract](https://pubsonline.informs.org/doi/10.1287/orsc.2.1.71)
- [San José State University: original research article used in teaching](https://strategy.sjsu.edu/www.stable/pdf/March%2C%20J.%20G.%20%281991%29.%20Organization%20Science%202%281%29%2071-87.pdf)


[Return to the learning courses](/en/lab/classics/learn)

[Download Markdown](/classics-data/modern/march.en.md)
