# Make It Stick

Peter C. Brown, Henry L. Roediger III, Mark A. McDaniel · 2014

Open the original and follow its chapters or sections with this study guide. Reading tasks are editorial assignments. Use the points to consider to examine your interpretation.

## Scope of source verification

Structure checked against: Contents or section structure

Checked the NTT Publishing eight-chapter contents, the authors’ first-chapter excerpt, and endnotes for all chapters. The entire book and every cited study were not reviewed. Study-planning tasks are independently created, and readers’ learning outcomes have not been measured.

- [NTT Publishing: complete translated chapter and subheading inventory](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/) — Contents
- [Authors: authorized first-chapter excerpt](https://www.makeitstick.com/about-make-it-stick) — Authorized excerpt
- [Authors: endnotes for all eight chapters](https://www.makeitstick.com/_files/ugd/99359a_b68cc695ab0b42cbaea9e8afe6d7e282.pdf) — Authorized excerpt

<a id="guide"></a>
## Read the whole work

Whole-work question: How can we design practice that turns a feeling of learning into understanding we can use after time has passed?

Edition: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2014; chapter structure cross-checked against the NTT Publishing 2016 Japanese translation, ISBN 9784757160668.

Native units: Substantive chapters

Form: Argument

Scope and divisions: All eight substantive chapters are followed in original order. Preface, notes, suggested reading, acknowledgments, and index are supporting material outside the eight-unit path. Part and unit headings and short bilingual chapter labels are editorial reading aids.

Checked: 2026-11-17

### Reading paths

Short path: [Question the feeling of learning](#guide-unit-assumptions) → [Retrieve without looking, then check](#guide-unit-retrieval) → [Vary spacing and combinations](#guide-unit-practice-schedule) → [Calibrate judgments of knowing](#guide-unit-calibration) → [Build a study plan to test over time](#guide-unit-application)

Full path: [Question the feeling of learning](#guide-unit-assumptions) → [Retrieve without looking, then check](#guide-unit-retrieval) → [Vary spacing and combinations](#guide-unit-practice-schedule) → [Choose difficulties that aid learning](#guide-unit-difficulty) → [Calibrate judgments of knowing](#guide-unit-calibration) → [Examine individual differences and methods](#guide-unit-learner-differences) → [Examine ability development and evidence](#guide-unit-ability) → [Build a study plan to test over time](#guide-unit-application)

### Parts and reading units

<a id="guide-part-learning-and-practice"></a>
#### Reconsider learning and practice

Native range: 1 · Learning assumptions — 3 · Mixed practice

Use the first three chapters to examine how learning is assessed and practice arranged. Distinguish immediate success from later retrieval.

<a id="guide-unit-assumptions"></a>
##### Question the feeling of learning

Native range: 1 · Learning assumptions · Read

Use chapter 1 to examine assumptions about learning. Specify what you want to learn and what you should be able to do later.

Question: Read chapter 1 and choose one study habit. Explain how to distinguish its immediate feel from actual attainment.

Points to consider:

- Assess speed during study separately from later use or recall.
- Distinguish anecdotes, explanatory theories, and evidence from comparative experiments.

Concepts: [Evidence of learning](#guide-concept-learning-evidence)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [1 · Learning assumptions](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/) — Compare the chapter’s ways of assessing learning with those you ordinarily use.

<a id="guide-unit-retrieval"></a>
##### Retrieve without looking, then check

Native range: 2 · Retrieval · Close reading

Read chapter 2 by distinguishing retrieval practice from tests used for grading. Include checking what was retrieved when designing practice.

Question: Using chapter 2, design a short exercise in explaining one unit with the guide closed and then checking it against the original.

Points to consider:

- Specify what to answer without looking and what to use for checking afterward.
- Record omitted relationships and mistaken explanations as well as correct answers.

Concepts: [Retrieval practice](#guide-concept-retrieval), [Evidence of learning](#guide-concept-learning-evidence)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [2 · Retrieval](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/) — Read for the purpose of retrieval and examine its roles in assessment and learning.

<a id="guide-unit-practice-schedule"></a>
##### Vary spacing and combinations

Native range: 3 · Mixed practice · Close reading

In chapter 3, examine spacing and the combination of problems separately. Distinguish becoming fluent with one problem from recognizing which approach a problem needs.

Question: Read chapter 3 and design two schedules with the same total study time but different spacing and mixtures of problems.

Points to consider:

- Separate changing review times from changing problem types.
- Arrange to compare immediate performance with later discrimination or application.

Concepts: [Spaced practice](#guide-concept-spacing), [Interleaving](#guide-concept-interleaving)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [3 · Mixed practice](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/) — Check distinctions among spaced, interleaved, and varied practice against the chapter’s subheadings.

<a id="guide-part-difficulty-and-calibration"></a>
#### Examine difficulty and self-assessment

Native range: 4 · Productive difficulty — 5 · Calibration

Read chapters 4 and 5 to connect practice difficulty with judgments of understanding. Consider how to observe change rather than merely count effort.

Depends on: [Reconsider learning and practice](#guide-part-learning-and-practice)

<a id="guide-unit-difficulty"></a>
##### Choose difficulties that aid learning

Native range: 4 · Productive difficulty · Read

Read chapter 4 by separating productive challenge from obstacles that prevent understanding the task. Do not judge every difficult exercise to be helpful.

Question: Investigate kinds of difficulty in chapter 4 and identify one challenge to try and one obstacle to remove first.

Points to consider:

- Identify prerequisite knowledge and available explanation or feedback.
- Check how a challenge relates to the learning objective before increasing difficulty.

Concepts: [Desirable difficulty](#guide-concept-desirable-difficulty)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [4 · Productive difficulty](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/) — Read back and forth between the discussions of productive and unproductive difficulties.

<a id="guide-unit-calibration"></a>
##### Calibrate judgments of knowing

Native range: 5 · Calibration · Read

Read chapter 5 to consider ways of observing differences between confidence and performance. Record predictions before answering so errors in judgment can be noticed.

Question: Using chapter 5, design a record comparing confidence before answering with the actual explanation, then decide what to change next.

Points to consider:

- Record confident errors separately from correct answers made with little confidence.
- Check whether confidence alone determines when you stop studying.

Concepts: [Calibration](#guide-concept-calibration), [Evidence of learning](#guide-concept-learning-evidence)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [5 · Calibration](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/) — Look for tools and habits for revising self-assessment and compare them with your record.

<a id="guide-part-differences-and-use"></a>
#### Move from learner differences to practice

Native range: 6 · Learning differences — 8 · Study practices

Read the later chapters to examine individual differences, developing ability, and study practices. Design a method to try and a way to check its effects.

Depends on: [Examine difficulty and self-assessment](#guide-part-difficulty-and-calibration)

<a id="guide-unit-learner-differences"></a>
##### Examine individual differences and methods

Native range: 6 · Learning differences · Read

Read chapter 6 by distinguishing preferences, current abilities, and the structure of material. Examine explanations and evidence before assigning yourself one fixed learner type.

Question: Open chapter 6 and consider a case where your preferred way of studying differs from a representation suited to the subject.

Points to consider:

- Separate recognizing individual differences from prescribing methods through fixed categories.
- Check whether you grasped the material’s structure and can use it on another problem.

Concepts: [Mental model](#guide-concept-mental-model), [Evidence of learning](#guide-concept-learning-evidence)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [6 · Learning differences](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/) — At the discussion of building structure, investigate its difference from merely listing information.

<a id="guide-unit-ability"></a>
##### Examine ability development and evidence

Native range: 7 · Developing ability · Read

Read chapter 7 by distinguishing what may change about ability from what remains unestablished. Keep motivational language separate from demonstrated effects.

Question: Choose one claim about ability from chapter 7 and record its evidence, scope, and conditions for trying it in practice.

Points to consider:

- Distinguish measures of the brain, task performance, and everyday skill.
- Separate an expectation of improvement from promising identical effects for everyone.

Concepts: [Developing ability](#guide-concept-developing-ability), [Evidence of learning](#guide-concept-learning-evidence)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [7 · Developing ability](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/) — Investigate how the discussion of developing ability connects to suggestions about practice.

<a id="guide-unit-application"></a>
##### Build a study plan to test over time

Native range: 8 · Study practices · Read

Read chapter 8 to build a plan for your role and subject. Go beyond adopting techniques by arranging an opportunity to check understanding later.

Question: Using chapter 8, create a plan including retrieval, spacing, mixed practice, and checking, and specify when to revise it.

Points to consider:

- Connect each practice to the aspect of the learning objective it is intended to support.
- Specify how to adjust an impractical plan and when to assess understanding.

Concepts: [Retrieval practice](#guide-concept-retrieval), [Spaced practice](#guide-concept-spacing), [Interleaving](#guide-concept-interleaving), [Calibration](#guide-concept-calibration)

Reading tasks to check in the original:

- [8 · Study practices](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/) — Find advice for a role close to yours and consider what would change for a different role.

### Key concepts

<a id="guide-concept-learning-evidence"></a>
#### Evidence of learning

Information from later recall, explanation, or application used to assess attainment beyond subjective impressions, with assessment timing specified.

First unit: [Question the feeling of learning](#guide-unit-assumptions)

<a id="guide-concept-retrieval"></a>
#### Retrieval practice

Practice in recalling information or ideas without looking, with checking and correction planned afterward.

First unit: [Retrieve without looking, then check](#guide-unit-retrieval)

<a id="guide-concept-spacing"></a>
#### Spaced practice

Arranging practice across separated times rather than one block; suitable intervals depend on the task and retention goal.

First unit: [Vary spacing and combinations](#guide-unit-practice-schedule)

<a id="guide-concept-interleaving"></a>
#### Interleaving

Mixing different kinds of problems or skills during practice, distinct from switching activities merely for distraction.

First unit: [Vary spacing and combinations](#guide-unit-practice-schedule)

<a id="guide-concept-desirable-difficulty"></a>
#### Desirable difficulty

Difficulty considered in relation to later retention or application, rather than valuing greater load for its own sake.

First unit: [Choose difficulties that aid learning](#guide-unit-difficulty)

<a id="guide-concept-calibration"></a>
#### Calibration

Comparing predicted understanding with actual responses to revise self-assessment.

First unit: [Calibrate judgments of knowing](#guide-unit-calibration)

<a id="guide-concept-mental-model"></a>
#### Mental model

A structured understanding of elements and relationships, examined when using learned information on a new problem.

First unit: [Examine individual differences and methods](#guide-unit-learner-differences)

<a id="guide-concept-developing-ability"></a>
#### Developing ability

An approach to investigating change through experience and practice, specifying which ability and measure are involved.

First unit: [Examine ability development and evidence](#guide-unit-ability)

### Misreadings and corrections (editorial examples)

Possible misreading: More difficult and painful practice always produces more learning.

Correction: Use chapter 4 to distinguish kinds of difficulty and examine conditions such as prior knowledge and support.

Check the passage: [4 · Productive difficulty](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/)

Possible misreading: If rereading feels fluent, learning is complete.

Correction: Investigate self-assessment in chapter 5 and include explanation without looking and later checks in your decision.

Check the passage: [5 · Calibration](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/)

Possible misreading: Because ability can change, effort makes everyone reach the same outcome.

Correction: Check the scope and evidence of claims in chapter 7 rather than turning possible development into identical promised outcomes.

Check the passage: [7 · Developing ability](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/)

<a id="guide-capstone"></a>
### Capstone

Design a plan for learning one subject and compare it with your previous approach. Specify total time, retrieval, spacing, problem mixtures, and correction. Decide how to check immediate and later understanding, then use chapters 6 and 7 to examine assumptions about differences and ability.

- Explain each method in relation to the learning objective.
- Record difficulty, confidence, and actual answers separately.
- Distinguish the observed scope of improvement from causes the comparison cannot establish.

Parts to connect: [Reconsider learning and practice](#guide-part-learning-and-practice), [Examine difficulty and self-assessment](#guide-part-difficulty-and-calibration), [Move from learner differences to practice](#guide-part-differences-and-use)

<a id="guide-scope"></a>
### Native scope inventory

1. [1 · Learning assumptions](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/)
2. [2 · Retrieval](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/)
3. [3 · Mixed practice](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/)
4. [4 · Productive difficulty](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/)
5. [5 · Calibration](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/)
6. [6 · Learning differences](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/)
7. [7 · Developing ability](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/)
8. [8 · Study practices](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/)

### Primary references

- [NTT Publishing: complete translated chapter and subheading inventory](https://www.nttpub.co.jp/book/detail/9784757160668/)
- [Authors: authorized first-chapter excerpt](https://www.makeitstick.com/about-make-it-stick)
- [Authors: endnotes for all eight chapters](https://www.makeitstick.com/_files/ugd/99359a_b68cc695ab0b42cbaea9e8afe6d7e282.pdf)


[Return to the learning courses](/en/lab/classics/learn)

[Download Markdown](/classics-data/modern/make-it-stick.en.md)
